Planned Preventative Maintenance vs Reactive Maintenance: What Your Business Actually Needs
Reactive maintenance feels cheaper. It rarely is.
The decision between planned preventative maintenance (PPM) and reactive maintenance is one every facilities manager and building owner faces. On paper, the case for reactive looks straightforward. You only pay when something breaks. No upfront schedules, no ongoing servicing contracts, no commitment.
The problem is that when things break in commercial buildings, they do not break cheaply or conveniently. This post sets out the real difference between PPM and reactive maintenance, what each approach actually costs, and why most commercial buildings benefit from using both.
What Is Planned Preventative Maintenance (PPM)?
Planned preventative maintenance is a scheduled, proactive programme of inspections, servicing, and minor repairs carried out on a building’s systems and assets before faults develop. The goal is to stop problems happening rather than respond to them after the fact.
A PPM contract typically sets out the scope of work, agreed timescales, and who is responsible for what. For example, a commercial electrician might carry out monthly emergency lighting checks and an annual full battery discharge test. All recorded, all scheduled, all part of a documented programme.
PPM covers a wide range of building services including HVAC systems, boilers and heating, electrical systems, fire alarm and suppression equipment, lifts, and water hygiene compliance.
What Is Reactive Maintenance?
Reactive maintenance means fixing things once they have already failed. The boiler goes off. You report it. An engineer comes out, diagnoses the fault, and repairs or replaces the component.
There is a place for reactive maintenance in any sensible building management strategy. Some assets are low-risk enough that it is not cost-effective to service them on a schedule. And even the best PPM programme will not eliminate all unexpected faults.
The problem arises when reactive maintenance becomes the default approach for critical building systems. That is when the costs, both financial and operational, start to add up.
The Real Cost Difference
Most reactive maintenance feels cheaper because the individual invoice looks smaller than a service contract. But that comparison ignores several things: emergency call-out rates, extended downtime, parts sourced at short notice, and the knock-on damage that a single failure can cause to connected systems.
Research suggests reactive repairs cost three to five times more than equivalent planned work when all direct and indirect costs are included. For a commercial building spending £250,000 a year on maintenance, a well-run PPM programme could save between £30,000 and £45,000 annually over a reactive-only approach.
Beyond the numbers, consider the disruption. A boiler that fails overnight in January means an emergency call-out, potential days without heating, and possibly staff unable to work. That disruption has a cost that never appears on a maintenance invoice.
PPM vs Reactive Maintenance: Side by Side
| PPM | Reactive Maintenance | |
| When work is done | Scheduled in advance | After a fault occurs |
| Cost per job | Lower, at planned rates | Higher, at emergency rates |
| Disruption to operations | Minimal, work scheduled around you | Can be significant with unplanned downtime |
| Compliance documentation | Structured and auditable | Often incomplete |
| Risk of cascading damage | Low, faults caught early | Higher due to late diagnosis |
| Best suited to | Critical systems and high-use assets | Lower-risk or low-use assets |
| Budget predictability | High, costs known in advance | Low, bills arrive unexpectedly |
What UK Law Requires
For many building services, PPM is not optional. UK health and safety legislation, fire safety regulations, and insurance policy conditions all place obligations on building owners and managers to maintain certain systems to a documented standard.
Emergency lighting, fire alarms, gas and electrical systems, and water hygiene controls all fall under specific compliance regimes that require regular, documented servicing. Depending on your sector, whether that is healthcare, hospitality, or local authority estates, those requirements become more detailed still.
A good PPM programme does not just protect your building. It creates the audit trail that demonstrates compliance. That matters when you have an insurance claim, a building inspection, or a dispute with a tenant.
The Case for a Hybrid Approach
The smartest building maintenance strategies do not treat PPM and reactive maintenance as a binary choice. They use both. PPM covers the systems that matter most, while reactive cover handles lower-priority assets and unexpected situations.
At TMS FM, this is the approach we build for our clients. We carry out a site assessment to identify which assets are business-critical, compliance-dependent, or likely to fail in a way that causes significant disruption. Those go on a PPM schedule. For everything else, we provide rapid reactive maintenance cover so that when something does go wrong, it gets sorted quickly.
It is a practical, cost-aware approach that protects what needs protecting without spending money servicing assets that do not warrant it.
When to Review Your Maintenance Strategy
If your current approach to building maintenance is mostly reactive, there are a few clear signs it might be time to change. Repeated call-outs for the same assets are a common one. If you are fixing the same boiler every winter, a PPM contract is almost certainly cheaper than the call-out cycle.
Other triggers include upcoming lease renewals, changes to your building’s use, a growing portfolio of sites, or a recent compliance issue that flagged gaps in your documentation.
Getting a fresh set of eyes on your maintenance strategy costs nothing. If you manage commercial property across multiple sites in retail, industrial, hospitality, or offices, TMS FM can help you find the right balance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is PPM legally required for commercial buildings in the UK?
For certain systems it is. Fire alarms, emergency lighting, gas appliances, and electrical installations all have statutory inspection and testing requirements under UK law. Water hygiene, particularly Legionella risk, also carries a legal duty of care. PPM provides the structured programme and documentation that demonstrates compliance with these obligations.
How often should PPM visits happen?
Frequency depends on the asset, manufacturer guidelines, building use, and applicable regulations. Some systems require monthly checks, others quarterly or annual. A good facilities management provider will recommend an appropriate schedule for each asset type rather than applying a one-size-fits-all frequency.
Can I switch from reactive to PPM mid-contract?
Yes. TMS FM works with businesses that are transitioning from a reactive-only approach to a more structured programme. The process starts with a site assessment to baseline the condition of your assets and identify priority areas.
Does PPM cover emergency repairs?
PPM does not eliminate the need for emergency reactive cover. Most PPM contracts sit alongside a reactive maintenance agreement so that if something fails unexpectedly, there is still a clear route to getting it fixed quickly. TMS FM provides both, coordinated through one team.
Is PPM worth it for smaller commercial premises?
For any premises with fire safety systems, electrical installations, or heating and cooling equipment, some level of planned maintenance makes sense. The scale of the programme will be smaller, but the compliance obligations are the same regardless of building size. A conversation with a facilities specialist is the best way to work out what is proportionate for your site.